THIS IS WAYSIDE.
It
is an old house, so old that it is impossible to tell just when it was built,
but in 1729 when Abraham Hyatt sold the property on which it stands to Thomas Hadden,
the deed read "Ye part of Manor of Scarsdale called Fox Meadow . . . houses,
barn, orchard, garden, fences . . . 100 acres for the sum of 1 $0 pounds".
Thus it is fair to assume that there was a house located on the plot in 1729,
and the rounded shingles and other structural features make some authorities
believe that it was built as far back as 1715.
In
about 1761 the Varian family acquired Wayside Cottage. The first member of the
Varians who lived in this country was Isaac, a butcher in the "Old
Slip" Market in 1720. James Varian, one of Isaac's five sons, was born in
New York City in 1734. He followed the trade of his father until the capture of
the city by the British during the Revolutionary War, at which time he moved to
Wayside in the so-called "neutral ground". When the British army
moved toward White Plains in October 1776, the Varians, hoping to secure some
of their possessions from plunder, removed a favorite cow and the family Bible
down into the cellar for safekeeping. Legend says that several sabre marks
still remain from one of the many attacks, and it is said that local boys spent
one summer picking bullets out of the shingles.
Colonel
Rufus Putnam, the chief engineer of Washington's Army, in his account of a
scouting trip made before the Battle of White Plains speaks of "riding as
far as three or four miles south of White Plains to a tavern and listening to a
conversation of Whig farmers". He could very well have been speaking of
Wayside. James Varian served as a first-lieutenant and then captain of the
Middle Battalion, Westchester County, and later his possessions were despoiled
by the "skinners and cowboys" who infested this area. He himself
became a helpless paralytic, caused by exposure in the patriot cause. He and
his family were driven from their farm by the British and took refuge at Danbury,
Conn., from which they returned after the peace was proclaimed.
After
James Varian died in 1800, his eldest son, Jonathan, and another son, James, Jr.,
jointly inherited this property. Jonathan was a drover by trade and probably
an innkeeper too, as in some books the house is referred to as Drovers' Inn. At
that time drovers used to drive the cattle to Wayside from the West. Both
cattle and men could refresh themselves here, the beasts on the rolling plains
outside and the men around the large fireplaces inside.
When
Jonathan died in 1824, his brother assumed the role of "mine host"
and there is reference in early Scarsdale writings to a "town meeting held
at the house of James Varian, Innkeeper, on April 7, 1829". James, Jr.,
was engaged in transporting the Boston mail in the first stage of the route
from New York City to New Milford, Conn. There was a large barn south of the
house, and the four-horse mail coach used to be driven under this while the
stop was made.
Another
James, this time the third of this name, took possession in 1841 and presumably
he lived there until 1853 when it was purchased by the Butler family. Legend
has it that Wayside may have been used during the Civil War as part of the
"underground railway" and this could very well be true. Emily Butler
was its owner for many years, and she was a kindly soul who let Mrs. Rutz-Reese
and her sister live here and teach music, and later allowed Louise Gunning and
Martha Washburn to have a tea shop and sell antiques within these walls.
In
1917 the United States entered World I and Miss Butler turned over thirty acres
of land as well as the house to the Scarsdale Community Farm, a plan originated
by Laura Crane Burgess to take Scars-dale off the food market and make it
self-supporting as far as winter vegetables were concerned. Boy Scouts cleared
the land, women cut and planted potatoes and many other vegetables. People
subscribed to the Community Farm and were paid wages when they worked there.
This
experiment was a success, in that people learned to work together side by side.
Miss Butler noticed this and wishing to make Wayside permanently available to
the people of Scarsdale, Miss Butler deeded Wayside to the Village of Scarsdale
in 1919 as follows; "for the purpose of creating an historical park and
for the preservation and maintenance of the ancient building for the use of
educational and historical purpose; for fostering a public and democratic
spirit in the community and providing a center for civic welfare, club rooms or
lyceum for the use of the people of Scarsdale."
The
Scarsdale Woman's Club was incorporated in January 1919 and the clubhouse,
Wayside Cottage, after extensive repairs and renovations, was opened in
December of that year. The Woman's Club made few structural changes and did all
they could to keep the pre-Revolutionary flavor of the place intact, including
furnishing it with authentic Windsor and Brewster chairs, tavern tables and
benches.
They
had a tearoom here and the Scarsdale Inquirer, under the aegis of the Woman's
Club, started in business at Wayside Cottage. As the years rolled by, the
Woman's Club outgrew the building and in 1928 they moved to larger quarters and
the Scars-dale Library became the next tenants. In 1951 the Library, in its
turn, moved to larger quarters, and for a year and a half Scarsdale's beloved
landmark was silent and empty.
The
Junior League of Scarsdale, Inc., was approached by the Village with a request
that, if it were interested in undertaking the project of Wayside Cottage and
becoming custodians of the building, it submit a proposal of its plans for
approval by the Village. In May 1953 the League, after a thorough study of
Wayside's condition and possibilities, submitted such a proposal, which met
with the approval of the Village and which was put into effect soon thereafter.
Much
costly restoration and renovation was done by the Junior League before Wayside
could be used as its headquarters and as a meeting place for other organizations
of the village. Partitions on the first floor were taken out in order to create
one large meeting room which is called the Emily Butler Room. The flooring and underflooring
were removed in order to install concrete beams and slabs, sleepers and underflooring.
Antique boards obtained from Rhode Island and Connecticut were laid on top and
then the boards were washed, hand sanded, and a beeswax and paste wax finish
put on them. A fireplace which the Library had boarded up on the north wall was
rediscovered and an antique mantel installed over it. The ceiling was repaired,
the entire south end of the building rewired, wainscoting extended around the
room, and it was painted along with the entire outside of the building.
A
partition was relocated in the kitchen; plumbing, linoleum and equipment were
installed, and the room was painted. One window in the Stack Room, an addition
built by the Library, was removed and a fire door installed. A soundproof ceiling
and new lighting were added. The Stack Room was later decorated as a colonial
sitting room and has recently been renamed the Tompkins Room after a prominent local
family.
The
Harvey Birch Chapter, Daughters of the American Revolution, completely
renovated the room, formerly the Children's Library. It was renamed the Harvey
Birch Room in honor of Cooper's "Spy" and his activities in this part
of the county. The original fieldstone fireplace was restored by removal of the
bricks and plaster, revealing the poplar lintel above and the oven inside. A
British half penny dated 1746 fell out of the nibble above the lintel. In this
room the ceiling and tile floor of the bathroom above were removed and old
beams exposed. The room has been restored and equipped with furnishings
appropriate to the pre-Revolutionary age of the building.
A
hand rail was installed on the stairs and a door at the top of them. Two
upstairs bedrooms were repaired, papered and painted. In the first bedroom a triangular
closet was discovered with a space behind it so that one could climb up to the
attic and down to the Harvey Birch Room beside the chimney. In the Woman's Club
Bulletin of 1919 it says, "There was a secret chamber which could be
entered by lifting the riser of the step going up to the center bedroom (now
the bathroom). This has since been opened into a closet." Another source
states that in the attic in a niche beside the chimney a tiny brick stair led
to a tunnel under Post Road which was a means of escape. Yet another account
declares that the tunnel went under Butler Field. It is possible that there
were two tunnels to which access was obtained by going down alongside the
central chimney.
This
bedroom has been recently restored to a colonial sitting room by funds
collected for the Jane W. Hackett Memorial Fund. Mrs. Hackett, at the time of
her death, was Scarsdale's Village Historian, and the room has been named and
dedicated in her honor.
A
great deal of the restoration of Wayside Cottage has been accomplished by hard
working League volunteers. Restoration, continued renovation and yearly
maintenance has been costly. To date, over $150,000.00 has been spent by the
Junior League on the Cottage. The League has always felt it worthwhile, however,
in preserving one of Scarsdale's most historic landmarks.
Two bi-centennial
open houses were held at the Cottage in 1976 and many came to learn of
Wayside's history. The 250th anniversary of Wayside was celebrated in May 1979
with an afternoon of colonial activities open to the community. The League's
efforts on Wayside's behalf were fully realized when Wayside Cottage was
included on the National Register of Historic Places. The community of Scarsdale
joined the Junior League in their celebration of this long awaited honor at an
official ceremony in October, 1981.
The
Junior League, as custodians of Wayside, continue to satisfy and nurture the
specifications of Miss Butler's original covenant. We are certain Miss Butler
would be pleased.
This story was published by the Junior League of
Central Westchester, Inc.